


Ever been to a party then gone home, only to find out later there was another room there where everyone was having a much, much better time? Sure, you liked listening to nice strangers make interesting points about progressive politics and bands you've never heard of, but after a few beers you would not have minded at all being in the middle of the naked dogpile pitting an Arizona tennis team against nine sailors from fleet week.
So it is with the long, deep, texty 500-page Secret Historian: The Life and Times of Samuel Steward, Professor, Tattoo Artist, and Sexual Renegade
and the big, bold, sexy 8.5" x 11" An Obscene Diary: The Visual World of Sam Steward. In fact, both are written by Justin Spring, but only the former is nominated for a National Book Award. The latter, a splendid companion volume of private sketches, watercolors, tattoo designs, and photos, is not getting nearly the attention it deserves. Many of the bookworm gays who love Secret Historian don't even know the Diary exists.
Talking to George Platt Lynes, Sam Steward dismissed his b&w Polaroids as "a kind of obscene diary... [with] no art." In his perfectly grounding intro essay, which is the only writing in the book, Spring says they're "something much more intimate, questioning, and personal," but admits these sex party souvenirs "were probably much more exciting to the participants than they are to us, today, as viewers." Although they form the massive share of the diary -- with three or four shots per page and more than two-thirds of book's unnumbered pages -- Spring notes:
Among all Steward's works, the Polaroid sex photographs are by far the darkest, most manic, most disturbing works in his collection. Steward himself never pretended that they were art, and he seemed not to find them sexually appealing either, confessing to Lynes, that "they leave me fairly cold." In truth, [they were not intended as pornography], that is, they were not created with the sexual stimulation of the viewer in mind. If anything, they are the by-products of sex play: souvenirs of outrageous, dangerous, and daring sexual exhibitionism."
"Dangerous" is an understatement at a time when mere possession of gay porn could mean jail. The images immortalize average to handsome men engaged in nudity, foreplay, kissing, oral, anal, threeways, bondage, spanking, and whipping, often with telling props or sailor caps and shirts. Some visual "stories" -- The Pick-Up, An Evening of Love, Surrender of Naval Forces, -- unfold shot by shot over several pages.
I prefer Steward's drawings, reflecting his numerous styles, which Spring variously likens to Thurber, Beardsley, Cocteau, classical Greek painting, Picasso, Felicien Rops, and the gay erotic artist Etienne. Anyone who has looked at Rockwell Kent's woodcuts will see similarities with the bed scene below.
Hooray for being able to use your phone to take pictures of a brand new friend making out with you, and instantly being able to text that photo to your teachers, coaches, and clergy, but as romantic keepsakes go, it's tough to top this: Steward wrote a porn novella called Bell-Bottom Trousers about the erotic adventures of a lusty sailor ashore in Chicago, illustrated key scenes of character development, and self-printed many copies using the hectograph machine at Loyola where he taught. He gave the booklet to the sailors he tricked with. It was the early 1940s. An Obscene Diary reproduces the chaste cover image and the two-page spread of fourteen naked sailors very much enjoying their liberty.
Three more risqué images, including the best watercolor in b&w, after the jump.
An Obscene Diary, out September 3, Antinous Press & Elysium Press. Handsomely slipcased, high production values.


